CD 1 - First Take

1. Compared to What 5:15
2. Angelitos Negros 6:55
3. Our Ages or Our Hearts 6:09
4. I Told Jesus 6:08
5. Hey, That's No Way to Say Goodbye 4:07
6. The First Time Ever I Saw Your Face 5:21
7. Tryin' Times 5:07
8. Ballad of the Sad Young Men 7:03

CD 2 - Quiet Fire

1. Go Up Moses 5:20
2. Bridge Over Troubled Water 7:13
3. Sunday and Sister Jones 5:01
4. See You Then 3:40
5. Will You Still Love Me Tomorrow 3:59
6. To Love Somebody 6:41
7. Let Them Talk 3:50
8. Sweet Bitter Love 6:06

CD 3 - Killing Me Softly

1. Killing Me Softly With His Song 4:46
2. Jesse 4:00
3. No Tears (In The End) 4:56
4. I'm The Girl 4:52
5. River 5:00
6. Conversation Love 3:38
7. When You Smile 3:42
8. Suzanne 9:45

CD 4 - Feel Like Makin' Love

1. Feelin' That Glow 5:48
2. I Wanted It Too 2:51
3. I Can See the Sun in Late December 12:48
4. Some Gospel According to Matthew 2:37
5. Feel Like Makin' Love 2:55
6. Mr. Magic 3:55
7. Early Ev'ry Midnite 5:54
8. Old Heartbreak Top Ten 4:22
9. She's Not Blind 5:24

CD 5 - Blue Lights in the Basement

1. Why Don't You Move in with Me 4:51
2. The Closer I Get To You 4:39
3. Fine, Fine Day 4:49
4. This Time I'll Be Sweeter 4:23
5. 25th of Last December 4:31
6. After You 3:55
7. I'd Like to Be Baby To You 4:37
8. Soul Deep 2:22
9. Love Is the Healing 3:42
10. Where I'll Find You 3:10